A Simulation-Based Tool for Predicting Whale-Vessel Encounter Rates
AUTHOR: ERIC KEEN, BENJAMIN HENDRICKS, CHENOAH SHINE, JANIE WRAY, CHRIS R. PICARD, HUSSEIN M. ALIDINA (2022)
PUBLICATION: Science Direct
ABSTRACT: To understand the threat of ship strikes for marine predators such as whales, quantitative tools are needed that measure specific impacts without ignoring the many uncertain and stochastic elements of whale-vessel interactions. We developed a tool that focuses on one particularly complex aspect of the ship-strike problem: the encounter rate, the fraction of co-occurrences (i.e., times that whales and vessels occur within the same 1-km2) that result in an imminent collision. This tool uses iterative simulations, based in R, and basic inputs regarding marine traffic and whale biology to predict the rate at which the precise courses of the whale and the vessel intersect in space and time. The result of this simulator is a spatially explicit probability distribution of encounter rates, which can be summarized for reports as well as integrated into subsequent stages of a ship-strike impact analysis. We explain the design of this tool, provide its source code, and demonstrate its utility with four case applications. First, we estimate encounter rates for fin whales (Balaenoptera physalus) in Gitga’at First Nation waters (British Columbia, BC, Canada) and quantify the differences in encounter rate between vessel classes. Second, we predict encounter rates for the same area in 2030, by which time a new shipping lane is slated to be established in Gitga’at territory, highlighting the impact of shifting traffic composition vs. traffic volume. Third, we assess the sensitivity of these estimates to changes in vessel and whale characteristics, finding that vessel length is the most important determinant of the encounter rate, followed by whale speed. Fourth, we integrate the encounter rate estimator into a shipping impact assessment for Gitga’at fin whales. Our predictions indicate that this decade’s traffic increase in Gitga’at waters alone could match Potential Biological Removal for coastal BC fin whales. However, the assumptions underlying our prediction require validation and further study. The encounter rate simulator is available in the R package, “shipstrike”.
Related Posts
To understand the threat of ship strikes for marine predators such as whales, quantitative tools are needed that measure specific impacts without ignoring the many uncertain and stochastic elements of whale-vessel interactions. We developed a tool that focuses on one particularly complex aspect of the ship-strike problem: the encounter rate, the fraction of co-occurrences (i.e., times that whales and vessels occur within the same 1-km2) that result in an imminent collision.
Fin whales (Balaenoptera physalus) are widely considered an offshore and oceanic species, but certain populations also use coastal areas and semi-enclosed seas. Based upon fifteen years of study, we report that Canadian Pacific fin whales (B. p. velifera) have returned to the Kitimat Fjord System (KFS) in the Great Bear Rainforest, and have established a seasonally resident population in its intracoastal waters.
Photo-identification (photo-ID) databases can comprise versatile troves of information for well-studied animal populations and, when organized well and curated carefully, can be readily applied to a wide range of research questions, such as population abundance estimates, meta-population connectivity and social network structure.
